Similarity
82% similar
ALT. FragrancesFireside Marshmallow
- Year
- —
- Concentration
- Eau de Parfum
- Bottle
- 60 ml
- Perfumer
- Not disclosed
- For
- Unisex
- Our rating
- 3.9 / 5
Price and where to buy
Typical price
$45
60 ml · $0.75/ml
−73%$120 less than Replica By the Fireplace
- Amazon$45Buy now
Prices are a guide and change often. We may earn a commission from these links at no extra cost to you. Disclosure · checked November 2, 2026
The original
Replica By the Fireplace
Maison Margiela
Fireside Marshmallow layers the same clove, chestnut and vanilla accords with a slightly sweeter, softer smoke.
82% similar$165 · 100 mlyou save 73%
Accords
- Smoky75 out of 100
- Vanilla70 out of 100
- Sweet65 out of 100
- Woody55 out of 100
- Warm Spicy50 out of 100
Performance
Longevity
3 / 5
Moderate · 4–6h
Sillage
3 / 5
Moderate
Notes
Notes
No tiers published
When to wear
Best in Winter · 95% suited
Our take
Fireside Marshmallow evokes crackling wood with warm clove, orange flower and vanilla. A note of chestnut adds a festive, roasted sweetness for cold evenings.
Similar
Replica By the Fireplace
Maison Margiela
$16571% overlapMelting Embers
Oakcha
$3371% overlap
Woody Chestnut
Dossier
$3270% overlapHercules
Maison Alhambra
$2549% overlap
Herod
Parfums de Marly
$29047% overlapAmbery Caramel
Dossier
$3246% overlap
Althaïr
Parfums de Marly
$40045% overlap
Noir Extreme
Tom Ford
$16544% overlap
Last updated November 2, 2026 · Similarity, ratings and descriptions are our own editorial judgement.